The GOP Got the Keys to the Gov’t — and Still Don’t Wanna Open It
- Ghetto Philosopher
- Oct 20
- 10 min read
Key Takeaway
The GOP’s refusal to open the government isn’t about fiscal conservatism. It’s about power, narrative control, and the normalization of chaos. Trump’s 2024 strategy depended on breaking faith in institutions so he could sell himself as the solution. But we’ve seen this hustle before. The 35-day shutdown of 2018–2019 during Trump's first term, caused by a dispute over expanding barriers on the U.S.–Mexico border. But like every old head will tell you — “Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.” The government may be closed, but the American people are watching. And this time, we know exactly who’s keeping the door locked.
Key Points
The Republican-led government shutdown isn’t about the budget — it’s about control, chaos, and Trump’s 2024 campaign strategy.
Speaker Mike Johnson is following Trump’s directive to “hold the line,” using dysfunction as political fuel.
The shutdown disproportionately impacts Black and working-class Americans, who make up a large share of the federal workforce and contractor base.
Every day the government stays closed costs billions in lost productivity, confidence, and wages — with no real fiscal savings.
Media coverage amplifies GOP chaos, allowing them to weaponize dysfunction and shift blame to the Democrats.
The shutdown is political hostage-taking — and Americans, especially Black communities, are paying the ransom.
The solution isn’t silence — it’s boycott and pressure, followed by vote and organize to hold chaos politics accountable.
Introduction
Let’s keep it real: this government shutdown drama ain’t about balancing the budget. It’s about political theater, plain and simple. The Republican Party — led by Speaker Mike Johnson, prodded by Donald Trump, and cheered on by MAGA Republicans — is refusing to open the government because chaos has become their campaign strategy. Shutdowns used to be a last resort. Now, they’re a ritual. Since 1980, the federal government’s gone through twenty shutdowns, but none as performative as this one. Trump, watching from Mar-a-Lago, has been pushing his people to “hold the line” — translation: keep the lights off until he gets the headlines.
Sidebar – Real Talk:
“This ain’t about saving money; it’s about saving face.”
The problem? Every day the government stays closed, hundreds of thousands of federal workers — many of them Black and brown — miss paychecks. Contractors lose hours. Small businesses that rely on federal customers dry up. And while politicians play chicken with paychecks, working Americans are the ones standing in traffic.
Why the “Schumer Shutdown” Is All Cap
When Republicans say Chuck Schumer “shut down the government,” it ignores how the Constitution and federal budget process divide power. Here’s the breakdown:
The House controls the purse strings. Article I, Section 7 of the Constitution says “All Bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives.” That means only the House can introduce spending bills to keep the government open. In this Congress, that’s a Republican-led House under Speaker Mike Johnson.
The Senate can’t vote on bills that don’t exist. If the House refuses to pass a continuing resolution (CR) or full-year appropriations, the Senate has nothing to take up. Chuck Schumer can’t “shut down” the government — he can only act on what Mike Johnson sends over.
Schumer has already advanced funding bills. The Senate, under Schumer’s leadership, has passed bipartisan appropriations measures and continuing resolutions — often with overwhelming Republican support. In contrast, the House has repeatedly stalled, amended, or rejected similar bills over political riders on immigration, DEI, and abortion.
Shutdowns happen when Congress can’t agree — not when one chamber refuses to yield. A shutdown is the result of failure to reconcile differences between the two chambers before the fiscal deadline. It’s inaccurate to claim that a single senator, even the Majority Leader, can unilaterally cause it.
The timeline shows where the blockade is. Legislative calendars show that the Senate passed its last CR weeks ago, while the House adjourned without voting on it. In that context, blaming Schumer is a political talking point, not a procedural fact.
It’s political deflection. Labeling it a “Schumer shutdown” serves to redirect blame away from internal Republican divisions — particularly between establishment conservatives and the far-right Freedom Caucus.
So when Republicans claim Schumer is to blame, it’s not legislative reality — it’s political theater designed to mask dysfunction within their own ranks.
Mike Johnson’s “Clean CR”? Man, Please. That Bill’s Dirtier Than a Gas Station Sink.
When Speaker Mike Johnson insists he’s offering a “clean CR,” it sounds responsible — like he’s just trying to keep the government open without political games. But anyone who’s read the text of these resolutions or followed the floor debates knows there’s nothing “clean” about them.
Here’s why:
1. A “Clean CR” Means No Policy Riders — His Bills Are Full of Them.
In Washington, a “clean CR” refers to a straight extension of current funding levels, without adding or removing policy conditions. Johnson’s version isn’t that.
His proposed CRs have included DEI bans, border policy restrictions, and anti-abortion language — all of which are policy riders unrelated to basic government funding.
According to Roll Call (Oct. 2025), Johnson’s CR included provisions to “halt funding for diversity and inclusion programs in federal agencies” and “restrict certain education and climate initiatives.”
Those are ideological demands, not fiscal necessities — and by definition, they make the bill unclean.
Translation:
“If you sprinkle politics in the pot, it ain’t clean soup no more.”
2. It’s Not a Short-Term Fix — It’s a Strategic Stall.
A genuine “clean CR” is usually a temporary measure (30–60 days) to keep operations running while Congress negotiates a full budget. Johnson’s proposal pushes short funding windows — some as short as two weeks — creating a “laddered” shutdown threat where different agencies run out of money at different times.
That’s chaos budgeting — not fiscal discipline. As Politico reported, Johnson’s staggered plan “injects more uncertainty into federal operations and keeps agencies in a constant state of near-shutdown.”
Translation:
“He didn’t clean the house — he just moved the mess into the hallway.”
3. He’s Using the CR as Leverage for Trump’s 2024 Agenda.
Johnson’s supposed “clean” CR comes with Trump-aligned priorities baked in:
Cuts to climate programs.
Delays on Ukraine aid.
Restrictions on DEI and education funding.
That’s not neutrality — that’s campaign messaging. Trump himself told GOP lawmakers (per Axios, Oct. 2025), “Don’t give Democrats a win — hold the line.” Johnson’s CR does exactly that: it’s designed to look functional while freezing anything that might help the Democrats show progress.
4. It Still Defunds Key Services by Freezing Dollars in a High-Inflation Economy.
Even without explicit cuts, keeping 2024 funding levels flat during inflation amounts to a real-term cut in agency capacity.Agencies like HUD, HHS, and Education face higher costs for rent, contracts, and payroll — meaning fewer services and delayed programs even if the top-line number “stays the same.”
A “clean CR” that ignores inflation is like promising to pay rent with last year’s paycheck — it looks stable until you do the math.
5. It’s a Branding Move, Not a Budget Plan.
Johnson is using the term “clean” the way advertisers use “organic” — not because it’s accurate, but because it sounds good. He’s trying to shift blame onto the Senate and House Democrats while still appeasing the far-right members of his caucus.
If it were truly clean, Democrats in the Senate would have passed it already. Instead, even moderates like Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski called it “needlessly partisan.” (CNN, Oct. 2025)
Translation:
“You can’t call it clean when it’s covered in fingerprints from the Freedom Caucus.”
Bottom Line
Mike Johnson’s “clean CR” is a political slogan, not a fiscal solution. It’s packed with conservative wish-list items, structured for short-term crisis management, and strategically built to align with Donald Trump’s 2024 campaign message of “Biden’s broken government.”
In other words, it’s not a continuing resolution — it’s a continuing disruption.
The Politics of Refusal
Speaker Mike Johnson’s refusal to pass a truly clean continuing resolution (CR) isn’t about fiscal discipline — it’s about loyalty. Trump’s fingerprints are all over this shutdown. Johnson’s playing follow-the-leader with Donald Trump, not leading the House. According to Politico reporting from October 2025, Trump has been telling GOP lawmakers that “a little chaos in Washington helps the campaign.” Translation: keep the government in gridlock so voters stay angry and exhausted. In Trump-speak, chaos equals control.
Meanwhile, Marjorie Taylor Greene and the Freedom Caucus keep dressing obstruction up as patriotism. They’re out here talking about “defending America from woke spending,” while hopping on Fox News to call Democrat’s programs “socialist slush funds.” But the numbers don’t lie — this same spending plan they’re blocking includes $886 billion for defense and $14 billion for border security. Ain’t nothing “woke” about that. It’s just politics in camouflage.
Sidebar – Real Talk:
“They screaming about socialism while cashing taxpayer checks.”
Economist Heather Boushey from the Washington Center for Equitable Growth told Reuters, “Government shutdowns cost far more than they save. They disrupt consumer confidence, federal services, and ripple through every sector.” The 2019 Trump shutdown alone cost the U.S. economy roughly $11 billion — $3 billion permanently lost, according to the Congressional Budget Office.
So why do it again? Because governing isn’t the goal. The goal is control of the narrative — making voters believe the system is broken so they’ll “need” Trump to fix it.
The Trump Strategy: Chaos as Campaign Fuel
Trump’s campaign thrives on disorder. The longer Washington stays messy, the more he can point and say, “See? America doesn’t work without me.”
Political scientist Melissa Harris-Perry called it a “strategic sabotage of confidence.” It’s a setup — Republicans create dysfunction, then campaign on fixing it. Speaker Johnson, in his October 2025 briefing, literally said, “We’re fighting to restore sanity in government spending.” But under his leadership, Congress hasn’t passed a single full-year appropriation.
This is Trump’s “burn it to rebuild it” logic: if America’s exhausted by dysfunction, maybe they’ll gamble on the chaos candidate one more time.
Sidebar – Real Talk:
“It’s like breaking your own car window to justify buying a new alarm system.”
The problem for them is — this time, people see the game. The Freedom Caucus isn’t negotiating for smaller government; they’re negotiating for airtime. Matt Gaetz and Lauren Boebert have spent more hours on Newsmax than in committee hearings. The MAGA faction knows that every news cycle they dominate is free campaign advertising.
Economic and Racial Fallout
Shutdowns hit working-class people first — and Black America hardest. During the 2019 shutdown, roughly 380,000 federal employees were furloughed without pay. The Bureau of Labor Statistics found that 18% of federal workers are Black, far above the national average. That means nearly one in five families in Black communities tied to federal employment lose stability every time the government closes.
And it doesn’t stop there. Federal contractors — from custodial staff to cybersecurity analysts — often get no back pay at all. The Washington Post reported that in 2019, nearly 1 million contract workers lost wages permanently. Many were minority-owned small businesses or essential workers who kept federal buildings running.
Sidebar – Real Talk:
“Shutdowns don’t just close buildings — they close refrigerators.”
Historically, the federal government has been one of the largest employers of Black professionals since desegregation. From the Civil Rights era to today, it’s been the route to stability and homeownership. Every shutdown chips away at that progress. It’s a quiet form of economic violence dressed up as political negotiation.
The Real MAGA Agenda
Let’s not get it twisted: this fight isn’t over “spending.” It’s over symbolism. MAGA Republicans want to dismantle Biden’s climate programs, diversity initiatives, and student loan relief. They want to erase DEI from every agency. Representative Chip Roy told The Hill, “We’re not funding woke policies — period.”
Translation? Programs that help poor people, students, and minorities are “woke,” but subsidies for oil companies or defense contractors are “patriotic.”
Sidebar – Real Talk:
“When they say ‘fiscal discipline,’ what they mean is ‘cut everything that helps you.’”
This isn’t new. The 1995 shutdown under Newt Gingrich tried the same playbook — weaponize government functions to score political points. Back then, Bill Clinton called it “the politics of personal destruction.” Today, it’s the politics of performative destruction.
Even Senate Republicans are growing tired. Senator Lisa Murkowski told CNN, “This is not governing. This is hostage-taking.”
The Media Feedback Loop
Every hour the government stays closed, Fox News and right-wing outlets push the same message: “Schumer won't open the gov't.” But it’s projection. The GOP knows most Americans don’t follow legislative procedure — they just see dysfunction and blame whoever Fox News says that caused it.
That’s the trick. Trump’s allies create chaos, then blame Democrats for the mess. The New York Times reported that Trump personally called Speaker Johnson urging him to “stand firm and show no weakness.”
Sidebar – Real Talk:
“This is political gaslighting at a national scale.”
The goal isn’t to govern — it’s to make government look ungovernable. And when the public loses faith in institutions, authoritarians win.
The Human Side of the Shutdown
Let’s bring it back home. Picture a TSA worker in Atlanta, a single mom who just missed her second paycheck. Or a National Park ranger in Arizona watching tourists turned away. Or a small-business owner in D.C. whose contracts are frozen.
These aren’t political abstractions — they’re people’s lives. The government might be an institution, but the pain is personal. Reverend Al Sharpton said it best on MSNBC: “When you weaponize the economy for political gain, you’re not leading — you’re looting.”
And for Black America, the shutdown becomes another layer of economic stress stacked on inflation, student loans, and housing costs.
What Comes Next
The question now is: how long can the GOP keep this up? Politically, not long. Gallup polls show that 68% of Americans blame Republicans for the shutdown. Business leaders are warning of downgrades to U.S. credit ratings. Even conservative donors are getting antsy.
But the long-term damage isn’t just financial — it’s psychological. Every shutdown teaches Americans to expect dysfunction. Every partisan stunt erodes confidence in democracy. That’s exactly what Trump wants going into 2026 and 2028 — exhaustion and apathy.
Sidebar – Real Talk:
“They want you tired, broke, and uninvolved — because that’s how they win.”
Conclusion: From Boycott to Ballot Box
So what do we do? First, boycott and pressure. Stop funding candidates and corporations that bankroll obstruction. Hold the line against businesses and PACs financing chaos. Economic pressure still speaks louder than hashtags.
Second, vote and organize. Don’t sit out because you’re angry — show up because you’re fed up. Vote in every election, not just the presidential one. Support down-ballot candidates who actually believe in government doing its job.
As the late John Lewis said, “Democracy is not a state. It is an act.”
Sidebar – Real Talk:
“Closed government, open eyes. Don’t just complain — campaign.”
Comments